You crack an egg into the pan and something looks off. Maybe it smells strange. Maybe the yolk breaks the second it hits the heat. Knowing whether an egg is good comes down to three checks: the expiration date on the carton, a smell test after cracking, and how the egg behaves in water or on a plate. A fresh egg sinks in water, has a firm yolk, and a thick white that stays close to the center. A spoiled egg floats, smells bad, and should go in the trash.
Those three checks are simple. The reasons behind them are what make them reliable. Once you understand why an egg floats or why the white thins out, you can judge an egg with confidence instead of guessing.
How Do You Tell If An Egg Is Good Step by Step?
Start with the carton. The date printed on it is the first and most reliable signal. In the US, egg cartons carry a Julian date — a three-digit code showing the day of the year the eggs were packed. Day 001 is January 1, and day 365 is December 31. Many cartons also show a “sell by” or “best by” date. Eggs are generally safe to use for a few weeks past that date if they have been stored properly, but quality drops as time passes.
Next, check the shell. It should be clean and uncracked. A cracked egg lets bacteria in, and the inside is no longer protected. If a shell is cracked at the store, leave it. If it cracks at home, cook it right away or throw it out.
Then do the water test. Fill a bowl with cold water and place the egg in gently.
- Sinks and lies flat: very fresh.
- Sinks but stands on one end: older but usually still fine to eat.
- Floats: old enough that the inside has changed. Do not eat it.
Finally, crack it into a separate bowl before adding it to anything else. Smell it. A good egg has almost no odor. A bad egg smells sour or sulfurous, and that smell is unmistakable. Look at the white and yolk too. A fresh egg has a thick white that holds its shape and a round yolk that sits up. An older egg spreads out and the yolk flattens.
Cracking into a separate bowl matters more than most people realize. If one egg in a batch is bad, you find out before it ruins the other three.
Why Does a Bad Egg Float?
An eggshell looks solid, but it is porous. Thousands of tiny pores let air move in and out. As an egg ages, moisture escapes through the shell and air takes its place inside. The pocket of air at the wide end of the egg — called the air cell — grows larger over time.
A fresh egg has a small air cell, so it is dense and sinks. An old egg has a large air cell, which makes it buoyant. Once enough air has built up, the egg floats. That is the whole mechanism. It is not a myth or a trick — it is basic physics.
One clarification worth knowing: floating does not always mean the egg is full of bacteria. It means the egg is old and its internal structure has broken down. An old egg is more vulnerable to bacteria and more likely to smell or taste bad, but the float test is really a freshness test, not a food-safety test on its own. That is why smell and appearance still matter. The float test tells you age. Your nose tells you spoilage.
What Does a Bad Egg Smell Like?
A spoiled egg smells sour, sulfurous, or plainly rotten. The odor comes from hydrogen sulfide and other compounds that form as the egg breaks down. It is strong and hard to miss. If you crack an egg and the smell makes you pull back, throw it out. Do not taste it to be sure.
A fresh egg, by contrast, has almost no smell at all. Some people detect a faint odor from the shell, but a good egg should not smell unpleasant. The smell test is one of the most dependable checks you have, because the human nose is very sensitive to the compounds that form in spoiled food.
If you are unsure, trust your reaction. A genuinely bad egg does not leave much room for doubt.
What Do the White and Yolk Tell You?
The inside of the egg shows its age clearly. A fresh egg has a thick, cloudy white that stays gathered around a round, firm yolk. As the egg ages, the white gets thinner and more watery, and the yolk flattens and shifts easily. The membrane that holds the yolk in place weakens over time.
Cloudiness in the white is normal and actually a sign of freshness. It comes from carbon dioxide still dissolved in the egg. Older eggs look clearer because that gas has escaped through the pores.
Blood spots or small meat spots inside an egg can look alarming. They are not a sign of a bad egg. They happen when a tiny blood vessel ruptures on the yolk surface as the egg forms, and they are safe to eat. You can remove them with the tip of a spoon if they bother you.
How Long Are Eggs Good After the Date on the Carton?
Refrigerated eggs usually stay good for several weeks past the date on the carton. The exact window depends on how the eggs were stored and how fresh they were when you bought them. Storage conditions matter more than most people think. An egg kept cold and steady lasts far longer than one left on the counter.
In the US, eggs are washed and refrigerated before sale, which removes the natural coating on the shell that helps protect the egg. That is why refrigeration is important here. In some other countries, eggs are sold unwashed and stored at room temperature, and the handling rules differ. If you buy eggs that were refrigerated at the store, keep them refrigerated at home.
Store eggs in the coldest part of the fridge, not in the door. The door is the warmest spot and the temperature swings every time you open it. Keep eggs in their original carton so they do not absorb odors from other food. A whole raw egg left out at room temperature should not sit there for long — the general food-safety guidance is to refrigerate promptly.
When Should You Throw an Egg Away?
Throw the egg away if it floats, if it smells bad, or if the shell is cracked and the egg has been sitting out. Any one of those is enough. You do not need all three to line up.
Also discard an egg if the white is discolored — pink, green, or iridescent — or if you see mold on the shell. Those are signs of bacterial growth, and cooking will not make them safe.
Handle raw eggs carefully. Wash your hands, the bowl, and any surface the raw egg touched with hot soapy water. Raw eggs can carry Salmonella, which is why cooking eggs thoroughly matters, especially for people who are pregnant, young children, older adults, and anyone with a weakened immune system. Those groups should avoid raw or runny eggs and dishes made with raw egg.
Does a Fresh Egg Always Mean a Safe Egg?
No. Freshness and safety are related but not the same thing. A fresh egg can still carry Salmonella on or inside the shell. That is why handling and cooking matter regardless of how fresh the egg is. The float test and smell test tell you about age and spoilage, not about bacteria you cannot see or smell.
This is the part most people miss. The checks in this article catch eggs that have gone bad from age or a broken shell. They do not detect every possible contaminant. Cooking eggs until both the white and yolk are firm is the reliable way to reduce the risk from bacteria. For most healthy adults, the risk from properly handled and cooked eggs is low. For the groups mentioned above, it is higher, and thorough cooking is the safer choice.
One more note on the water test. It works best for whole eggs in the shell. Once an egg is cracked, the test tells you nothing — use your eyes and nose instead.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you eat an egg that floats?
No. A floating egg is old and its inside has broken down, so it should be thrown away. Floating alone does not prove spoilage, but it is reason enough to discard it.
How can you tell if an egg is bad without cracking it?
Use the float test and check the carton date. A fresh egg sinks and lies flat in water, while an old egg stands up or floats.
Is it safe to eat eggs after the sell-by date?
Usually yes, if they have been refrigerated the whole time and pass the smell and float checks. Quality drops with age, so use them soon.
What does a bad egg smell like?
A spoiled egg smells sour or sulfurous, like rotten eggs. A fresh egg has almost no smell.

